Armorial stamp on no. 28 (image courtesy of Federico Macchi)
The bindings are mostly brown goatskin, the covers decorated either with strapwork ornament (often enamelled or silvered), or with gilt corner and centrepieces. Each has Paolo Giordano’s armorial gilt stamp, the shield divided per pale, showing on the viewer’s left the Orsini symbols of the rose and eel, and on the right the sei palle of the House of Medici, lettered around “Pavl Iordan Vrs D. Aragon”.
The books are all in Italian, with two exceptions: Erasmus’s Adagiorum, in the edition Basel 1551, and Guillaume Rondelet’s treatise on fish and aquatic mammals printed at Lyon in 1554. A young man’s interest in warfare and in the lives of ancient and modern men of arms is apparent: Appianus’ Civil Wars, Caesar’s Commentaries, Procopius’ Persian wars, Polyaenus’ Stratagems, Cornazzaro’s military tract, Biondo’s Roman history, Roseo’s Lives of the emperors, the Antiquities of Annio da Viterbo, the modern histories of Capella and Corio, and three works by Giovio, including his account of the military campaigns of Gonzalo Fernández de Córdoba. Also, three books of philosophy: Xenophon, Guevara’s fictionalised life of Marcus Aurelius, and León Hebreo’s Dialogues on the nature and philosophy of love; a Bible; Vitruvius’s Architecture; Daniele Barbaro’s edition of Speroni’s Dialogues; and literature: Bandello’s Novelle, three works of Boccaccio, epistolary collections of Aretino and Bembo, and Bembo’s models of verse composition. Three of the Italian books were printed at Florence (Torrentino editions of Giovio’s histories, 1549-1553), two at Lucca (Busdraghi’s edition of Bandello, 1554), the others are Venetian imprints. The earliest book was printed in 1522, the latest in 1554, which suggests that the books were obtained in Italy, and were taken to France for binding.5
Working partly from illustrations, Mirjam Foot assigned nine bindings to an unidentified Parisian atelier, designated “Wotton Binder C” on account of its work for the English bibliophile Thomas Wotton, and another (Boccaccio, Il Decamerone, 1522), with hesitation, to a craftsman known as the “Cupid’s Bow Binder”.6
Anthony Hobson assumed that Paolo Giordano was “no bibliophile” because he “did not trouble to acquire any bindings during the last thirty years of his life”.7 A recent study by Barbara Furlotti, based on inventories found in Roman archives, proves that Hobson was mistaken: Paolo Giordano did continue to acquire books, however they have either been lost, or bear no recognisable evidence of his ownership.
After his marriage to Isabella (1558), Paolo Giordano became determined to replicate the splendour of the Medici court. He committed himself to an orgy of spending, collecting and commissioning paintings, tapestries, antiquities, sculpture, and especially furnishings, accumulating in Rome and at his castle at Bracciano huge quantities of table silver, embroideries, silk wall and bed hangings, rugs and pillows, in luxurious fabrics, colour-coordinated, and usually trimmed with silk. That taste for varied and brilliant colours extended into Paolo Giordano’s library, where – on the evidence of these inventories – he shelved books bound in, red, yellow, and green velvet, in red, green, blue, and white leather, some bichrome, many with red or blue silk ties. On the whole, these are quite unusual preferences for bookbindings, and suggest strong bibliophile tastes.8
The earliest of the inventories itemises some 75 books which Paolo Giordano brought to Bracciano in 1575.9 As in most early book lists, a few entries are so truncated or abbreviated, that the text cannot be identified; in most cases, the edition cannot be determined. No more than five or six entries correspond to works which Paolo Giordano gave in 1556 to Parisian bookbinders.10 Surprisingly, 26 entries are for books in Latin. By 1575, Paolo Giordano was reading Latin editions of Appianus Alexandrinus, Gaius Iulius Caesar, Giovanni Della Casa (Ioannes Casa), Marcus Tullius Cicero, Quintus Curtius Rufus, Euclides, Flavius Josephus, Raffaele Maffei (Raphael Volaterranus), Martialis, Flaminio Nobili (Flaminius Nobilius), Publius Ovidius Naso, Plutarchus, Ioannes de Sacrobosco, Lucius Annaeus Seneca, Terentius Afer, Valerius Maximus, Publius Vergilius Maro, and Xenophon.
As many of the Italian books in this inventory were first published years after Paolo Giordano’s return from Paris, it is certain that his book acquisitions did not cease then, but continued. Mentioned in the inventory (date of first printing in parentheses) are copies of Giovanni Battista Ramusio, Secondo volume delle nauigationi et viaggi (1559); Antonio Francesco Cini, Successi dell'armata della m.ta c.ca destinata all'impresa di Tripoli di Barberia (1560); Il Monte di Feronia nel quale si contengono le cose d'arme fatte in Ferrara nel carneuale (1561); Statuti capitoli et constitutioni del Ordine de caualieri di santo Stephano (1562); Francesco Cattani da Diacceto, L'essamerone (1563); Baccio Baldini, Discorso sopra la mascherata della geneologia degl'iddei de' gentili (1565); Domenico Mellini, Descrizione della entrata della serenissima regina Giouanna d'Austria et dell'apparato, fatto in Firenze (1566), Battista De Ruberti, Osseruazioni de astrologia et altre appartenenze, circa della medicina, & mutazione de' tempi (1567), Scipion Lembo, Trionfi della santissima lega et impresa de Leuante (1572), Francesco de’ Vieri, Trattato delle metheore (1573).
Several works are by authors who attended either his or the Medici court, and these might be presentation copies. The enigmatic inventory entry “All’ illustrissimo et eccellentissimo signore, il signor duca di Braciano signore mio observandissimo” could refer to Poesie toscane, et latine di diuersi eccel. ingegni (1563), a book edited by Lodovico Domenichi, containing a dedication to Paolo Giordano which commences with that phrase. Four volumes in the inventory are by Francesco Sansovino: Delle orationi volgarmente scritte da molti huomini illustri de tempi nostri (1562-1575), Origine de caualieri (1566), and two copies of L’historia di casa Orsina (1565). This last work, a lavishly illustrated folio, had been commissioned by Paolo Giordano. The inventory entries for the two copies are exceptional, in that the compiler has specified their bindings: “de veluta verda”, in green velvet.
A second inventory, prepared by the guardaroba, in 1577-1581, lists books kept in Paolo Giordano’s residences in Rome, Bracciano, and Florence.11 On this occasion, material characteristics were recorded, not the text inside. According to Furlotti’s transcription of the document, 36 volumes were then in Rome, and 42 in Bracciano. Nearly all the volumes kept in Rome are described as “con l’arme di sua eccellenza”, bound in leather of various colours: 15 in white leather (corame) with blue silk ties, 8 in red leather with red silk ties, 7 in green and red leather with silk ties, 2 in green leather with silk ties. One entry records in Rome a “Libro di disegni,” “coperta di carta pecorina [i.e. parchment, or vellum] con l’arme di sua eccellenza”. The great majority of the books kept at Bracciano were bound in vellum; just eight were in goatskin (all bearing his arms), and three in velvets of different colours, including one in yellow velvet adorned with his arms and seven silver bosses. In this inventory, the contents are noted only twice: “quindici pezzi di libri da musicha con coperta di corame biancho con l’arme di sua eccellenza con fettuccia di seta turchina, numero 15”, and a copy of Caesar’s Commentaries.12 Paolo Giordano’s copy of Rondelet’s treatise on fish, in a vellum binding with his arms (no. 26), is not recognisable in the inventories. It possibly was acquired in France, but bound after his return to Italy. A third inventory, listing Paolo Giordano’s possessions at Bracciano, in 1582, lists (somewhat differently) the same 42 books; one is identified as “un libro di carta pecora pagonazo con l’arme di sua eccellenza”.13 A fourth, compiled by a notary shortly after Paolo Giordano’s death (13 November 1585), lists the contents of his Roman palace in the Campo de’Fiori.14 Sixteen volumes are recorded: the same 15 books of music entered in the 1577-1581 inventory, bound in white leather with Paolo Giordano’s arms on covers and blue silk ties;15 and a small prayer book bound in vellum.
The disposition of Paolo Giordano’s artworks after his death has been widely investigated, however nothing is yet known of the immediate fate of his books. Only a few volumes have recognisable evidence of ownership before the 19th century (see nos. 2-3, 5, 28, with inscriptions of “Pier Francesco Alex. et Amicorum”).
Inscription on title-page of no. 28 (image courtesy of Federico Macchi)
1. Geoffrey D. Hobson, “Une reliure au Musée d’Art et d’Histoire” in Genava 9 (1931), pp.204-207.
2. Tammaro De Marinis, Appunti e richerche bibliografiche (Milan 1940), pp.129-131 (“IX. Legature Francesi del Cinquecento in Raccolte Italiane”, nos. 43-46, 7 bindings are mentioned, and 6 are illustrated).
3. Anthony Hobson, French and Italian collectors and their bindings illustrated from examples in the library of J.R. Abbey (Oxford 1953), no. 18. Sotheby & Co., Catalogue of valuable printed books, fine bindings, autograph letters, literary mss. and historical documents, London, 8-9 November 1960, lot 393 (stating that 21 Orsini bindings, including one remboîtage are known). [RBH 08Nov1960-393]
4. Federico & Livio Macchi, “Le legature francesi di Paolo Giordano Orsini d'Aragona: Storia di un personaggio e di una legatura” in Misinta 45 (June 2016), pp.143-149 [link]. Reprinted from L’Esopo 29, nos. 111-112 (2007), pp.41-56.
5. Investigation of a record of Paolo Giordano’s expenses during his trip to France might resolve the question. That document (Rome, Archivio Storico Capitolino, Archivio Orsini, II, 2055) is cited by Barbara Furlotti, A Renaissance Baron and his possessions: Paolo Giordano I Orsini, Duke of Bracciano (1541-1585) (Turnhout 2012), p.8.
6. Mirjam Foot, The Henry Davis Gift: a collection of bookbindings, Volume I: Studies in the history of bookbinding (London 1978), p.150 (assigning our no. 8 Boccaccio, Il Decamerone, to the Cupid’s Bow binder), pp.152-154, “Appendix V: Bindings by Wotton’s Binder III (Wotton binder C) for other collectors”, nos. 9 (Vitruvius), 11 (Cornazzano), 18 (León Hebreo), 33 (Biondo, Roma trionfante), 34 (Giovio, Le vite di Leon decimo), 38 (Aretino, Lettere), 43 (Polyaenus), 46 (Guevara), 47 (Corio).
7. Hobson, op. cit., p.38.
8. Furlotti, op. cit., pp.85-86.
9. Rome, Archivio Storico Capitolino, Archivio Orsini, II, 1208, ff.38v-39r: A di 18 agosto 1575. li robe di la guardarobe mandato a Braciano. Transcription by Furlotti, op. cit., pp.283-291.
10. Nos. 11 Caesar, 13 Corio, 18-19 Giovio, 20 Guevara, 25 Procopius, and 4 or 5 Bembo.
11. Rome, Archivio Storico Capitolino, Archivio Orsini, II, 1205: Inventario generale dell’illustrissimo signor Paolo Giordano. The inventory is organized according to category of object, rather than location; section “L” includes “libri diversi”. Transcription by Furlotti, op. cit., pp.215-232 (Libri diversi, pp.218-219).
12. The Caesar is entered as “un libro di corame verde et rosso profilato d’oro con l’arme di sua eccellenza con sua fettuccia di seta nominato li comentarii di Cesare, numero 1” (Furlotti, op. cit, p.219); it might be the copy bound for Paolo Giordano in Paris. The 1575 inventory had listed three copies of Caesar’s Commentaries: one in Italian as “Comentarii di Caio Giulio Cesare traduta di latina vulgare” and two in Latin as “C. Iulii Caesaris commentariorum” and “C. Iulii Caesaris rerum ab se gestarum commenta” (Furlotti, op. cit., pp.284, 285, 288). Furlotti op. cit., p.6, cites a document recording Paolo Giordano’s gift in 1579 of a copy of Caesar to his eight-year-old son Virginio (Rome, Archivio Storico Capitolino, Archivio Orsini II, 2061, fol. 158r).
13. Rome, Archivio Storico Capitolino, Archivio Orsini, I, 412, f. 1, no. 3, ff.1r-16v. Transcription by Furlotti, op. cit., pp.233-254 (p.238).
14. Rome, Archivio Storico Capitolino, Archivio Urbano, I, 301, Benardino de’ Notariis, no. 360, ff.1r-18v: Inventario di beni mobili ritrovati nel palazzo di Campo di Fiore dove habitava l’illustrissimo et eccellentissimo signor Paulo Giordano Orsino, duca di Bracciano di buona memoria…. Transcription by Furlotti, op. cit., pp.254-282 (p.270).
15. “sei libri da musica coperti di corame bianco con l’arme di sua eccellenza indorati con fettuccie turchine | nove libri simili piegati in traverso” (the latter in oblong format?). Furlotti, op. cit., p.270.
(1) Appianus, Delle guerre ciuili et esterne de romani (Venice: Bartolomeo Cesano, 1550)
Images courtesy of Federico Macchi
provenance
● Paolo Giordano Orsini, duca di Bracciano (1541-1585), armorial supralibros, lettered “Pavl Iordan Vrs D. Aragon”
● unidentified owner, inscription “di P.o F.o Alex. et Amico[rum]” [see above nos. 2-3, 5]
● Parma, Biblioteca Palatina, GG III. 165 (opac [link])
(29) Vitruvius Pollio, M. L. Vitruvio Pollione Di architettura dal vero esemplare latino nella volgar lingua tradotto (Venice: Niccolò Zoppino, March 1535)
(31) Statuta Concilii Florentini (Florence: Bartolomeo Sermartelli, 1564)
provenance
● Sotheby & Co., Catalogue of valuable printed books, 15-16 February 1960, lot 520 (“inserted into a Parisian binding of 1556 with the arms of Paolo Giordano Orsini (1535-85), decorated to an architectural pattern, badly rubbed, sides Laid down, rebacked”) [RBH 15Feb1960-520]
● Maggs, Bros - bought in sale (£200)
(32) Paolo Sarti, La simmetria dell’ottima fortificatione regolare (Venice: Evangelista Deuchino, 1630)
provenance
● Paolo Giordano Orsini, duca di Bracciano (1541-1585), armorial supralibros, lettered “Pavl Iordan Vrs D. Aragon”
● Zisska & Lacher, Katalog 62, Munich, 6 November 2013, lot 403 (“the richly gilt, but unfortunately stronger rubbed and worn old cover material is one of ca. 20 preserved bindings or remains of a book cover from the collection of Paolo Giordano Orsini d’Aragona Signore di Bracciano e Anguillara (1541-1585), with his armorial bookplate and the lettering all around ‘Paul Jordan Urs d’Aragona’ … Calf of the 19th century with applied leather cover material of the 16th century on both sides (scratched, scuffed) [link]
● Kiefer Buch und Kunstauktionen, Auktion 112, Pforzheim, 14-15 February 2020, lot 547 [link]
Francesco Sansovino, La historia delle cose fatte in diuersi tempi da’ signori di casa Orsina (Venice: Niccolò Bevilacqua, 1564)
provenance
● Ludovico Orsini [Furlotti, op. cit., p.51, identifies him as a son of Girolamo, from Monterotondo branch of the Orsini family; this volume not owned by Paolo Giordano, as was argued by Bredekamp]
literature
Horst Bredekamp, Vicino Orsini und der heilige Wald von Bomarzo: ein Fürst als Künstler und Anarchist (Worms 1991), p.130