The German custom of recording the date of acquisition on a binding suggested to Anthony Hobson that the owner was a German student on a peregrinatio academica in France. The motto “Patriae et Amicis” is associated with the noble Pfinzing family of Nuremberg, and Hobson identified Martin Seifried Pfinzing von Henfenfeld (1547-1579) as the member of the family most likely to have been studying in France in 1568.
Judging by the large number of exlibris commissioned by members of Pfinzing family,2 they were passionate book collectors and accumulated sizeable libraries, notwithstanding the few volumes containing an exlibris which have survived. In 1555, Paul Pfinzing (1523-1570) devised with the Nuremberg printmaker Virgil Solis a woodcut exlibris portraying the newly-dignified family insignia with a new motto, “Patriae et Amicis,” lettered around a scene of Marcus Curtius in front of the abyss, an image of male bravery, referring perhaps to his or his father’s exploits in the campaign against the Turks.3 The same motto and scene of Marcus Curtius appear on two portrait medals, cast in 1555-1556, recording Paul’s appointment as an imperial councillor and personal secretary to Charles V and to Philip II of Spain.4 Paul subsequently commissioned from the printmaker Matthias Zündt of Nuremberg three etched versions of Solis’ woodcut exlibris, each with the “Patriae et Amicis” motto, two of which are dated 1569.5 His elder brother, Martin II (1521-1572), who had married in 1544 Katharina Scherl, commissioned meanwhile two exlibris: one from Zündt, about 1565, displaying the Pfinzing and Scherl insignia side-by-side (without a motto);6 the other from Jost Amman, about 1568, showing the Henfenfeld arms alone (motto: Deus Videt).7 When Philip II left for Spain, Paul accompanied him to Madrid, and he died there in 1570. Martin II thereafter took some of Paul’s Zündt exlibris with the “Patriae et Amicis” motto for his own use, personalising them by adding his name on the blank tablets; later members of the family did likewise. It is notable, however, that neither of Martin II’s two portrait medals, nor medals made for other family members, use the motto “Patriae et Amicis”.8 This, presumably, was the personal motto of Paul, not a family motto.
Martin Seifried – Hobson’s candidate for the commissioner of these bindings – was Paul and Martin II’s half-brother (by Martin I’s second wife, Barbara Tetzel). Nothing is known of his education, however in 1568 he made an entry in an album amicorum kept by a student at Tübingen university, Johann Ulrich Starck (matriculated 21 May 1568). Martin Seifried’s brother, Johannes (1546-1582), placed his autograph in the same album on 23 August 1570,9 however neither Martin Seifried nor Johannes is recorded as a student in Tübingen. In 1569, Martin Seifried married Catharina Starck von Reckenhof, and became an Assessor in Nuremberg, where he died in 1579, aged 32. On some impressions of Zündt’s exlibris the blank tablet is filled (using a second engraved plate) with the motto “Saluti Patriae Vixisse Honestat”. Hobson reasoned that Martin Seifried had “dropped” use of his first name, and that such impressions of the exlibris were used by him personally, the initial letters of the motto (S.P.V.H.) signifying instead Seifried Pfinzing von Henfenfeld.10
If these thirty-seven bindings bearing the motto “Patriae et Amicis” and date “1568” are indeed associated with the Pfinzing family, then Paul Pfintzing most probably was their owner. Paul died, unmarried, at Madrid on 30 August 1570, and although the disposition of his library is uncertain, the books most likely remained in Spain.11 It may be no coincidence that a large number of the “Patriae et Amicis” bindings were in Spanish ownership in the late seventeenth or early eighteenth century. Eleven, possibly 13 volumes, have the distinctive shelfmarks of the library formed by Gaspar Téllez-Girón, 5th Duke de Osuna (1625-1694).12 Another eleven, possibly fourteen volumes, contain the ownership inscription of the Jesuit Pierre Robinet (1656-1738). Sometime professor at Pont-à-Mousson and Strasbourg, rector of the Jesuit Colleges at Strasbourg and Reims, Robinet had been appointed Confessor to Philip V in 1705,13 and in 1712 became director of the royal library in Madrid. He assisted in the consolidation of the King’s personal collection, and gathered books confiscated from the libraries of Antonio Folch de Cardona, Archbishop of Valencia, and other rebels. In 1715, Robinet returned to Strasbourg, becoming again rector of the Jesuit College, to which he bequeathed his library.14 Did Robinet acquire his fourteen “Patriae et Amicis” bindings – seven volumes of Cicero, three of Livy, editions of Sallust, Justinus, Diogenes Laertius, Dionysius Halicarnassus – while in Spain, or later, on the French market?
Three of the eight books in Anthony’s Hobson’s list are decorated in gilt with interlacing ribbons and hatched tools, in a style dubbed “pre-fanfare” or “type primitif”. The Herodotus (no. 22) is decorated to a different pattern, however it features the same tulip tool:
The Martialis (no. 28) is decorated by cornucopia corner-blocks, these seemingly identical to those found on a Plantin imprint of 1566,15 and on a book bound in Paris about 1580.16 The three bindings have no tools in common.
Left “Patriae et Amicis” binding No. 28 : Martialis (Antwerp: Plantin, 1568)
Centre Comparative illustration (on Plantin Ovid 1566) (Meurnier Pl. 71)
Right Comparative illustration (“Paris, atelier non identifié, vers 1580”) (BnF reliures [link]
Three books in Anthony’s Hobson’s list, all three Plantin imprints published 1566-1568, among them the Martialis (no. 28), are decorated by the same cartouche. Hobson noted that it resembles, but is not identical, to a cartouche used in Paris in 1566 on a binding for a Swiss student, Ludwig zur Gilgen [image, link].17
Left “Patriae et Amicis" binding, No. 28 : Martialis (Antwerp: Plantin, 1568)
Centre Comparative illustration (Flemish binding, on Plantin Ovid 1566) (British Library [link])
Right Comparative illustration (Parisian binding for Ludwig zur Gilgen, dated 1566) (British Library [link])
1. Geoffrey D. Hobson, Maioli, Canevari and others (London 1926), p.48; G.D. Hobson, Les reliures à la fanfare: le problème de l’S fermé (London 1935), p.5. Mirjam Foot, “Some bindings for foreign students in 16th century Paris” in The Book Collector (1975), pp.106-110 (p.106); reprinted without revision in Foot’s Studies in the history of bookbinding (Aldershot 1993), pp.324-328. Anthony Hobson, “Three plaquette bindings and a German collector” in Bibliophilies et reliures: Mélanges offerts à Michel Wittock, edited by Annie de Coster & Claude Sorgeloos (Brussels 2006), pp.264-269 (pp.267-268 nos. 1-8; Hobson’s 1-8 are nos. 16, 14, 9, 23, 29-30, 28, 25 in the present List).
2. Claudia Valter, “Die Exlibris der Nürnberger Patrizierfamilie Pfinzing” in Mitteilungen des Vereins für Geschichte der Stadt Nürnberg 100 (2013), pp.227-256 [online].
3. Woodcut exlibris from two blocks by Virgil Solis, following a painted design in an imperial charter granted 1 July 1555; see Valter, op. cit., Abb. 2 (charter), Abb. 3 & 5 (Solis woodcut, upper block only); Hollstein’s German etchings, engravings & woodcuts 1400-1700. Volume 65: Virgil Solis, Part II (Rotterdam 2004), no. 972 (full sheet, the tablet in the lower block lettered “Paulus Pfintzing von Heuffenfelt Roemischer Kaiserlicher Maiestat unnd Königklichern Würden zu Hisbanien unnd Engellandt Rath und Secretari”).
4. Luc Smolderen, Jacques Jonghelinck: sculpteur, médailleur et graveur de sceaux (1530-1606) (Louvain 1996), pp.208-210 nos. 1-2 & Pl. LVII.
5. (1) Signed and dated 1569: Valter op. cit., Abb. 6; Friedrich Warnecke, Die deutschen Bücherzeichen Ex-Libris von ihrem Ursprunge bis zur Gegenwart (Berlin 1890), no. 1569; Ilse O’Dell, Deutsche und Österreichische Exlibris 1500-1599 im Britischen Museum (London 2003), no. 296. (2) Signed: Valter, op. cit., Abb. 7; Warnecke 1567; O’Dell 294. (3) Signed and dated 1569: Valter, op. cit., Abb. 8; Warnecke 1568; O’Dell 295.
6. Valter op. cit., Abb. 10; O’Dell, op cit., no. 298.
7. Valter op. cit., Abb. 11; O’Dell, op. cit., no. 297.
8. Christophe Andreas, Sammlung eines Nürnbergischen Münz-Kabinets, Ersten Theils, zwote Abtheilung (Nuremberg 1782), Cap. XII: Pfinzing von Henfenfeld, pp.620-647 (Paul’s medals: pp.636-637, nos. 34-35; Martin II’s medals: p.635, nos. 31-32). A uniface medal with Pfinzing arms and motto “Devs Videt” is recorded by Andreas, op. cit., p.632 no. 24 [link]. For the mottos appearing on portrait medals of Paul’s uncle, Melchior I Pfinzing (1481-1535), editor of the “Theuerdank”, see Manuel Teget-Welz, “Spes Mea in Devm. Melchior Pfinzing und die Renaissancemedaille” in Jahrbuch für Numismatik und Geldgeschichte 62 (2012), pp.273-298. His exlibris (an engraving by Barthel Beham, ca 1530) had no motto (O’Dell, op. cit., no. 293).
9. Nuremberg, Germanisches Nationalmuseum, Hs 113 302. Martin Seifried contributed a scene of two men on horseback; see H. Höhn, “Alte Stammbücher im Besitz des Germanischen Nationalmuseums zu Nürnberg” in Zeitschrift für Bücherfreunde, N.F. 5 (1913), pp.1-11 (p.3 & Abb. 1) [link]; Lotte Kurras, Die Stammbücher. Teil 1, Die bis 1750 begonnenen Stammbücher [in Germanisches Nationalmuseum Nürnberg] (Wiesbaden 1988), pp.5-6 no. 5.
10. The epitaph on Martin Seifried’s tomb in Pfarrkirche St Nikolaus, Henfenfeld, however, states his full name: “Martin Seifrid. Pfintzing Ab. Henffenfeld Martinii Sen: Fil. VI”; see Hartmut Scholz, Die mittelalterlichen Glasmalereien in Mittelfranken und Nürnberg (extra muros) (Berlin 2002), p.200 no. 13 [online]. The Zündt exlibris were repeatedly re-struck for use by Martin II’s family: one is pasted in the album amicorum, bound in 1605, of his last-born son, Hanns Ludwig (Bamberg, Staatsbibliothek, Msc. Hist. 176) [digitised, link]. The initials S.P.V.H. thus could refer to Seifried (1556-1586) or Sigmund (1558-1594), older brothers of Hanns Ludwig. The Zündt Pfinzing exlibris were in use for more than a century: an impression with “Martin Pfintzing von Henfenfeld 1678” written on the tablet is in the British Museum (O’Dell, op. cit., no. 296).
11. Pierre Blasco, “Le testament de Paul Pfintzing” in Iberica II: Cahiers ibériques et iberico-américains de l’Université de Paris-Sorbonne (Paris 1980), pp.181-192.
12. Eduardo Peñalver Gómez, “Libros procedentes de la biblioteca del Duque de Osuna” in Fondos y procedencias: bibliotecas en la Biblioteca de la Universidad de Sevilla (Seville 2013), pp.287-292 [online]; Óscar Lilao Franca, “La biblioteca de la Casa de Osuna en las bibliotecas universitarias españolas: Marcas de procedencia” in Pecia Complutense 22 (2015), pp.34-44 [online]. The Osuna library was acquired by the Spanish state in 1884 and the books distributed between the national and university libraries.
13. María Luisa Cuesta, “Jesuitas confesores de reyes y directores de la Biblioteca Nacional” in Revista de archives, bibliotecas y museos 69 (1961), pp.129-174.
14. Aloys De Backer & Carlos Sommervogel, Bibliothèque de la Compagnie de Jésus. Première partie Bibliographie (Brussels & Paris 1895), VI, col. 1923.
15. Reproduced by Charles Meunier, Cent reliures de la Bibliothèque nationale ([Paris] 1914), Pl. 71.
16. Paris, Bibliothèque nationale de France, Rés. Z PAYEN-2 (Michel de Montaigne, Essais, Bordeaux: Simon Millanges, 1580). Reproduced by Meunier, op. cit., Pl. 70; Trésors de la Bibliothèque nationale de France. Volume I, Mémoires et merveilles, VIIIe-XVIIIe siècles (Paris 1996); no. 76; reliures.bnf.fr [link].
17. See also Mirjam Foot, The Henry Davis gift: a collection of bookbindings, 3: A catalogue of south-European bindings (London 2010), no. 73. This student, born in Lucerne, matriculated at Freiburg, Paris, Dole, and Orléans; the binding is lettered “Lvtetiae 26 Iuni Anno 1566”.
(1) Appianus, De civilibus Romanorum bellis historiarum libri quinque (Lyon: Heirs of Sébastien Gryphe, 1560) [FB 53608, 16mo]
provenance
● unidentified owner using motto “Patriae et Amicis” (Paul Pfintzing?)
● Strassburg, Médiathèque André Malraux, C 1104 (opac, link; Catalogue collectif de France (hereafter ccfr) Belle rel. ancienne avec la légende: Patriae et amicis et la date: MDLXVIII”)
(2) Marcus Tullius Cicero, De officiis M.T. Ciceronis libri tres Eiusdem, De Amicitia, De Senectute Dialogi duo: cum Paradoxis, & Somnio Scipionis. Omnia denuo, optimis quibusque collatis exemplaribus diligentißime castigata (Lyon: Sébastien Gryphe, 1555) [FB 61946, 16mo]
provenance
● unidentified owner using motto “Patriae et Amicis” (Paul Pfintzing?)
● Pierre Robinet (1656-1738), inscription recording his donation to
● Collège Royal, du Séminaire Épiscopal, Strasbourg, “Coll. Reg. Arg. S.J., ex dono R.P. Petri Robinet Regi Cathol. à confess.” (Schlaefli)
● Strassburg, Bibliothèque du Grand Séminaire, 1 Ih 23
literature
Louis Schlaefli, Catalogue des livres du seizième siècle (1531-1599) de la bibliothèque du Grand Séminaire de Strasbourg (Baden-Baden 1995), no. 644 (“Reliure à Grolier datée de 1568”)
(3-4) Marcus Tullius Cicero, Marci Tulii Ciceronis De philosophia tomus primus (Lyon: Sébastien Gryphe, 1548), bound with Cicero, Philosophicorum M.T. Ciceronis Tomus II (Lyon: Sébastien Gryphe, 1548) [FB 61749 / 61760, 16mo]
provenance
● unidentified owner using motto “Patriae et Amicis” (Paul Pfintzing?)
● Pierre Robinet (1656-1738), inscription recording his donation to
● Collège Royal, du Séminaire Épiscopal, Strasbourg, “Coll. Reg. Arg. S.J., ex dono R.P. Petri Robinet ….” (Schlaefli)
● Strassburg, Bibliothèque du Grand Séminaire, 1 Ih 22
literature
Schlaefli, op. cit., no. 646 (“2 vol. in 16° … Reliure à Grolier de 1568”)
(5) Marcus Tullius Cicero, Epistolae ad Atticum, Brutum, & Q. Fratrem (“Lyon: Sébastien Gryphe, 1561” - Lyon & Turnbull)
provenance
● unidentified owner using motto “Patriae et Amicis” (Paul Pfintzing?)
● Pierre Robinet (1656-1738), inscription recording his donation to
● Collège Royal, du Séminaire Épiscopal, Strasbourg
● Lyon & Turnbull, Rare books, manuscripts, maps & photographs, Edinburgh, 4 May 2016, lot 178 (offered among “Other properties”; sextodecimo, “contemporary embossed vellum, elaborately gilt incorporating ‘Patriae et Amicis’ and ‘MDLXVIII’ on sides, gilt edges, rubbed, upper cover detached”) [RBH 461-178; catalogue online, link; FB 62126-7 are Lyon “apud Jean Frellon” and “apud Antoine Vincent” editions of 1561, in 16mo; none with Sébastien’s name; USTC does not record a Sébastien Gryphe “1561” edition; if printed by him, perhaps “apud Sébastien Gryphe, 1551” or “apud héritiers Sébastien Gryphe, 1560” (a 1567 edition is “apud Antoine Gryphe, 1567”)]
(6) Marcus Tullius Cicero, M. T. Cice. Epistolarum, ut vocant, familiarium libri XVI denuo, collatis non paucis venerandae fidei exemplaribus, quam accuratissime castigati (Lyon: Sébastien Gryphe, 1553) [FB 61903, 16mo]
provenance
● unidentified owner using motto “Patriae et Amicis” (Paul Pfintzing?)
● Pierre Robinet (1656-1738), inscription recording his donation to
● Collège Royal, du Séminaire Épiscopal, Strasbourg, “Coll. Reg. Arg. S.J., ex dono R.P. Petri Robinet ….” (Schlaefli)
● Strassburg, Bibliothèque du Grand Séminaire, 1 Ih 20
literature
Schlaefli, op. cit., no. 649 (“Reliure à Grolier de 1568”)
(7) Marcus Tullius Cicero, M. Tullii Ciceronis Orationum tomus primus (Lyon: Sébastien Gryphe, 1550) [FB 61819, 16mo]
provenance
● unidentified owner using motto “Patriae et Amicis” (Paul Pfintzing?)
● Pierre Robinet (1656-1738), inscription recording his donation to
● Collège Royal, du Séminaire Épiscopal, Strasbourg, “Coll. Reg. Arg. S.J., ex dono R.P. Petri Robinet ….” (Schlaefli)
● Strassburg, Bibliothèque du Grand Séminaire, 1 Ih 24
literature
Schlaefli, op. cit., no. 652 (“Reliure à Grolier datée de 1568”) [edition in 3 volumes; Schlaefli gives pagination for vol. 1 only, not certain vols. 2-3 are present]
(8) Marcus Tullius Cicero, M. T. Cic. Rhetoricorum ad Caium Herennium libri quatuor. De inventione libri duo (Lyon: Sébastien Gryphe, 1555) [FB 61968, 16mo]
provenance
● unidentified owner using motto “Patriae et Amicis” (Paul Pfintzing?)
● Pierre Robinet (1656-1738), inscription recording his donation to
● Collège Royal, du Séminaire Épiscopal, Strasbourg, “Coll. Reg. Arg. S.J., ex dono R.P. Petri Robinet ….” (Schlaefli)
● Strassburg, Bibliothèque du Grand Séminaire, 1 Ih 21
literature
Schlaefli, op. cit., no. 654 (“2 tomes en 1 vol. in-16°, 12 cm. Reliure à Grolier de 1568”)
(9) Diogenes Laertius, De vita et moribus philosophorum (Antwerp: Christophe Plantin, 1566) [FB 65093, 16mo]