Nineteen bindings are now recorded with the impresa of a serpent entwined around a key, with motto “Scilicet is superis labor est” (For sure, this is work for gods - Vergil, Aeneid, 4.379), stamped in gold in the centres of both covers. Inside are books in Latin printed between 1517 and 1566, at Basel, Cologne, Florence, Lyon, Mondovì, Paris, and Venice, with Lyonese and Venetian imprints predominating. Two stamps were made, one (66 x 48 mm) for duodecimos and octavos, the other (91 x 68 mm) for books in quarto and folio format. The decoration is restrained: on the larger books, a frame composed of multiple gilt lines, with either a fleuron or fleur-de-lys at the corners; on the smaller ones, a frame containing foliage, with the same fleur-de-lys in corners. Red goatskin is employed for modern authors, olive or brown goatskin for ancient authors and ancient subjects. Each volume has a title lettered in the upper compartment, or vertically down the spine, suggesting how the books were displayed in their owner’s library.
Left Small stamp (66 x 48 mm) [no. 12] – Right Large stamp (91 x 68 mm) [no. 9]
The bindings attracted the eye of Guglielmo Libri, who collected three, recognising them as Italian bindings, albeit with a device appearing in Claude Paradin’s collection, Devises heroïques (Lyon 1557). E.P. Goldschmidt, who recorded two, thought the bindings might be Lyonese.1 By 1934, seven bindings were known to G.D. Hobson, who ventured that they were “probably Roman”.2 Anthony Hobson listed ten bindings in 1953, declaring them to be “unquestionably Roman” and, in view of the high proportion of books printed north of the Alps, speculating that they belonged to a foreigner, perhaps a Frenchman residing in Rome.3 By 1980, Hobson had reconsidered. His investigation of the libraries of the patrician families of Genoa, that of Giovanni Battista Grimaldi in particular, led him to believe that the owner was a Genoese nobleman.4 In 2012, Hobson delivered the name of a likely owner, Tommaso Franzone, and provided an updated list of 17 books (in 18 volumes) decorated with the coiled-snake device.5 (A 19th volume is added in the list below.)
Tommaso di Gaspare Franzone (d. 1627) belonged to the entrepreneurial “new” nobility of Genoa. He revived the family’s fortunes through astute participation in the silk trade and laid the foundations for their subsequent social ascent, serving twice as senator, and ensuring that his sons Agostino (1573-1658) and Anfrano (d. 1621) married into old families and held public offices. In 1602 he commenced building a villa in Albaro and in 1606 bought the Palazzo di Nicolò Spinola in via Luccoli.6
Hobson assumes that the coiled-snake bindings were made for Tommaso in the mid-1560s, some ten years after the Genoese banker and financier, Giovanni Battista Grimaldi (1524?-1612), had installed his library of about 200 volumes in a newly built villa near Genoa. Comparing Grimaldi’s bindings, adorned with the famous plaquette of “Apollo & Pegasus”, with the coiled-snake bindings, Hobson notes striking similarities: the Franzone and Grimaldi bindings both utilise impresa blocks of two sizes, both have spine titling in the same positions, both follow an eccentric colour scheme (red goatskin for modern authors, olive for ancient), and although bound twenty years apart in different shops, both have certain technical and decorative features in common. Hobson believes that Grimaldi’s library inspired Tommaso, and that in bibliophilic matters Tommaso was Grimaldi’s protégé. He adduces as evidence of that relation a book from Grimaldi’s library which contains Tommaso’s signature.7 Moreover, three of the recorded coiled-snake bindings were once in the possession of Anfrano Mattia di Gaspare Franzone (1646-1679), Tommaso’s great-grandson.8
The small number of tools on the coiled-snake bindings have not allowed identification of the binder. Hobson found no tools in common with those in the kit of the local Grimaldi Binder, and could not exclude the possibility that the shop was located elsewhere.9
1. S. Leigh Sotheby & John Wilkinson, Catalogue of the choicer portion of the magnificent library, formed by M. Guglielmo Libri, London, 1-15 August 1859, lots 2036 (Pigna), 2558 (Suetonius), 2748 (Vico). E.P. Goldschmidt, Gothic & Renaissance bookbindings exemplified and illustrated from the author’s collection (London 1928), no. 247 (Macrobius).
2. Geoffrey Hobson, in Sotheby & Co., Catalogue of valuable printed books, autograph letters & literary manuscripts, London, 1-3 August 1934, lot 291.
3. Anthony Hobson, French and Italian collectors and their bindings illustrated from examples in the library of J. R. Abbey (Oxford 1953), p.136 no. 66, p.182 (Appendix D: Bindings with the same impresa as no. 66, Scilicet is superis labor est).
4. Anthony Hobson, “La biblioteca di Giovanni Battista Grimaldi” in Atti della Società Ligure di Storia Patria 20 (1980), pp.108-119 (p.118: “Il possessore è ancora da identificare. Bisognerebbe cercarlo fra i nobili genovesi che facevano costruire delle ville suntuose intorno agli anni 1560-1565.”).
5. Anthony Hobson, “A Genoese book collector” in Gutenberg-Jahrbuch 2012, pp.208-212.
6. Giuseppe Odoardo Corazzini, Memorie storiche della famiglia Fransoni (Florence 1873), pp.42-44.
7. Anthony Hobson, Apollo and Pegasus: an enquiry into the formation and dispersal of a Renaissance library (Amsterdam 1975), no. 69.
8. Nos. 10 (Macrobius), 12 (Thomas More), 15 (Ptolomaeus). Anfrano Mattia, the son of Gaspare di Anfrano di Tommaso (d. 1657) and Maria Maddalena Sauli, donated 50 books to the Augustinian friar Lodovico Aprosio’s Bibliotheca Aprosiana, the first public library of Liguria (ed. Hamburg 1734, pp.71-80).
9. For the Grimaldi Binder, see Hobson, op. cit. 1975, pp.97-100.
(1) Rodolphus Agricola, Rodolphi Agricolae lucubrationes aliquot lectu dignißimae (Cologne: Johann I Gymnich, 1539)
“Olive goatskin” (Hobson)
Image courtesy of Federico Macchi
provenance
● Tommaso Franzone (d. 1627), supralibros, purported user of impresa with motto “Scilicet is superis labor est”
● Marchese Francesco Casati, inscription “ex libris Francisci Casati”
● Bartolomeo Casati, inscription “Ex libris Bartholomei Casati Placentini” [acquired by the Biblioteca Palatina between 1761 and 1785; Bartolomeo, the son of marchese Francesco Casati, lost the Castello della Boffalora and other assets in (bankruptcy) 1704]
● Parma, Biblioteca Palatina, BB IX.25956 (Inventario PAL 39488) (opac pelle; sui piatti filetti impressi a secco, filetti, decorazioni e stemma con motto (Scilicet is superis labor est) impressi in oro; sul dorso nervature, decorazioni, nome dell’A. e tit. impressi in oro [link])
literature
Mostra storica della legatura artistica in Palazzo Pitti (Florence 1922), no. 197 [link]
Hobson, op. cit. 1953, Appendix D, no. 2
Hobson, op. cit. 2012, no. 3
(17) Gaius Suetonius Tranquillus, Duodecim Caesares, cum commentariis, et annotationibus (Lyon: Jean Frellon, 1548)
“Olive-brown goatskin” (Hobson)
(19) Marcus Junianus Justinus, Ex Trogi Pompeii historiis externis libri XXXXIIII. His accessit ex Sexto Aurelio Victore de vita et moribus Romanorum imperatorum epitome (Lyon: Sébastien Gryphe, 1555)
Red goatskin